Blogs
and traditional media, in the eyes of many, are diametrically opposed in their
missions, qualities, and content. However, as blogs have evolved from their
origins as “weblogs” of daily activities into the huge variety of news reports,
themed information, daily or weekly stories, and all of their other flavors,
some of them have become much closer to the mainstream media than many might
have believed possible, years ago. This does not mean, though, that more
traditional media sources will become obsolete as blogs take over their
functions. In fact, many of the blogs that have the closest relationship to
traditional news outlets also have the greatest need for them.
Firstly,
most news-oriented blogs still rely on the mainstream media for their information,
but take the facts and provide an analysis or opinion on them rather than the
simple, more “journalistic” reporting of the media. For example, in the article
“New Media, Old Media,” by the Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in
Journalism, it is stated, “more than 99% of the stories linked to in blogs came
from legacy outlets…,” which include such organizations as CNN and The Washington Post (1). However, rather
than merely restating the facts of the news, “bloggers have largely taken on a
different role – one of observation, analysis, and interpretation,” as Homero Gil
de Zuñiga writes in Blogging as a Journalistic
Practice (589).
This role of
interpretation is aided by the fact that, on a blog, it is possible for the
public to comment directly on a story, and for a wide variety of opinions to be
heard at any given time. As the Pew Research Center study found, “unlike in
some other types of media, the partisanship here does not lean strongly to one
side or the other,” with a mix of liberal and conservative voices chiming in on
most issues (“New Media, Old Media” 1). This is in stark contrast with
traditional media, which are often either biased strongly for one side or
interested only in reporting the facts, and not what they mean, especially in
the most traditional media, newspapers, where the only way to include
“comments” from the general public is through Letters to the Editor.
Because
of the distinct differences in style and application between online news and
traditional news sources, and the fact that online media almost always refer to
established media for their story sources, it seems that both sources of news
stories will stay relevant in the future. Blogs can “scrutiniz[e] their
[mainstream media’s] reporting, hold[…] their feet to the fire, and keep[…]
stories alive until large news organizations pay more attention,” while the
mainstream media can, at the very least, provide fodder for bloggers looking
for a scapegoat (Gil de Zuñiga 589). These two complementary sources are very
much here to stay.
Works
Cited
Gil
De Zuñiga, Homero, Seth C. Lewis, Amber Willard, Sebastian Valenzuela, Jae Kook
Lee, and Brian Baresch. "Blogging as a Journalistic Practice: A Model
Linking Perception, Motivation, and Behavior." Journalism 12.5
(2011): 586-606. Sage. Web. 28 Mar. 2012. <http://jou.sagepub.com/content/12/5/586.full.pdf+html>.
"New
Media, Old Media." Project for Excellence in Journalism. Pew
Research Center, 23 May 2010. Web. 28 Mar. 2012. <http://www.journalism.org/analysis_report/new_media_old_media>.
I like your take on traditional and modern media. They really are complimentary. To make news blogs relevant and reliable, they must take information from traditional media. I hope that you are right about traditional news sticking around.
ReplyDelete